By JON BRADY
Updated: 19:42 AEDT, 21 November 2024
983
View
comments
Branding experts have reacted with confusion and bafflement at Jaguar's new rebrand - which has shed the iconic 'growler' badge amidst a technicolour marketing push that doesn't feature any cars.
The British sports car marque has been fiercely criticised over its most dramatic rebrand in decades, which swaps the roaring big cat badge for a roundel containing two letter 'J's and swaps the imposing font of the logo for a softer typeface.
It comes as Jaguar puts its entire range out to pasture and pauses new car sales for an entire year as it develops its entirely new range of all-electric vehicles, to go on sale from 2025 with a much younger audience in mind than in the past.
The redesign attracted fierce criticism. Californian designer Joseph Alessio said it would be 'taught in schools as how not to do a rebrand,' while another designer labelled it 'one of the most destructive marketing moves ever attempted.'
And public relations experts have told MailOnline they are stumped by the firm's decisions - from the 'vandalism' of the company's iconic logo to the apparent casting off of decades of motoring heritage to attract new buyers.
Brand and culture expert Nick Ede says he was 'baffled' by the marketing push - which featured precisely no cars - while Oli Garnett, co-founder of creative design agency Something Familiar, called the rebrand a 'dog's dinner'.
Jaguar, meanwhile, has doubled down on the rebrand, sending sassy and saccharine replies to detractors on social media who question the wisdom of moving away from the kind of thinking that birthed iconic vehicles such as the E-Type.
Some owners have even threatened to end their car deals early to, in the words of one social media user, 'avoid the humiliation of being seen in one again'.
Jaguar's new rebrand has attracted accusations the company has gone 'woke' - as it launched the new look with an advert featuring no cars
The advert features boldly dressed fashion models in bright primary colours alongside slogans such as 'break moulds' and 'create exuberant'
This is the new Jaguar logo - a roundel made up of the letter 'J' that looks the same both ways up
The classic Jaguar 'growler' logo has been ditched as the car firm reinvents itself to appeal to a younger audience of car buyers
The rebrand was unveiled yesterday with a video showing exuberant models walking through an alien landscape to a techno music soundtrack. It ended with the slogan: 'Copy nothing', inspired by a slogan uttered by Jag's founder, Sir William Lyons.
Mr Garnett said: 'It's a real shame because they had an opportunity, with all their history, and they've opted to rebrand it as a sort of, Gen Z-type operation.
'They're losing the legacy of the brand. Just because it's an electric brand now doesn't mean you can't still be modern, and sharp, and fast and aggressive.
It is all, in Ms Riaz's words, 'too much'. She added: 'There's a lot of emotional touchpoints with Jaguar - British craftsmanship, excellence, luxury. This is alienating the core customer base.
'We have an association with Jaguar, when we see that logo with the teeth-bearing cat. They're going for the future but their customers aren't there yet.'
Branding the rebrand launch a 'damp squib', Mr Ede continued: 'Why is it so important for Jaguar to strip back everything from its past, which made it into the brand that it is today, just to start again?
'As a brand you've got to, not modernise, but change and evolve. But it's all in the storytelling - and the story they're telling in this advert tells us nothing.'
It described its new philosophy as embracing 's bold designs, unexpected and original thinking' that will 'command attention through fearless creativity'. It has certainly done that.
Gerry McGovern, the car firm's design boss, said yesterday he wanted to create a 'jaw-dropping' redesign that will 'shock, surprise and polarise'.
'It will make you feel uncomfortable. That's fine. The world is not standing still,' he said at a launch event yesterday.
And as Jaguar sends saccharine responses to detractors on social media, Mr Ede has questioned the wisdom of potentially putting off future customers.
Gerry McGovern, Jaguar's chief creative officer, is unapologetic over the redesign. He said yesterday: 'It will make you feel uncomfortable. That's fine'
Jaguar has given short shrift to the outrage on social media - and even invited Elon Musk, boss of direct rival Tesla, to the launch event for its new concept car in Miami
'I feel like Jaguar don't know where they are. They're talking about alienating literally all their customers, which is a really bad thing to do, especially with a British heritage brand.
'Others like Barbour, they keep their heritage in the background because it's important to them, it gives them authenticity and gravitas.
'Whereas Jaguar seems to be saying, "no, no, we don't care about anyone who has bought one of our cars, It's all about the future now".
'It feels like they're almost embarrassed by it, and that to me is a huge faux pas because it feels like they should be playing on the fact they have been around for 100 years.
'Before, when somebody picked you up in a Jag, it felt fantastic, classy, glamorous.
'Instead, we're seeing these fabulous models wearing brilliant designs but it feels like a complete disconnect... stripping away all of their heritage and making a massive gamble on the future. It's just confusing.'
The radical look is part of Jaguar's complete reimagination as it races ahead of the 2030 deadline for car firms to stop selling petrol and diesel cars in the UK.
Jaguar is set to unveil a new car - not a production model, but a 'design' concept showing off how its new cars will look - in Miami on December 2.
But Mr Ede expects the firm to jump the gun and release images early to temper the furious reaction to the rebrand online - so people remember that Jaguar is, after all, a car company.
On a base level, there's no denying people are talking about Jaguar more than they have in years. The firm has seen sales fall dramatically as its range has shrunk; time will tell if it has the renaissance it is hoping for.
Mr Ede said: 'It's getting headlines and they're getting everywhere. No matter what, we're all talking about Jaguar. Sometimes, this can work in your favour.'
Ms Riaz added: 'Jaguar are being very ambitious. Maybe they knew what they were doing. But I think it's a shame because it's losing their history, the legacy of the brand. It's too much.
'People say there's no such thing as bad publicity but this will be a test of that.'
Some links in this article may be affiliate links. If you click on them we may earn a small commission. That helps us fund This Is Money, and keep it free to use. We do not write articles to promote products. We do not allow any commercial relationship to affect our editorial independence.
Published by Associated Newspapers Ltd
Part of the Daily Mail, The Mail on Sunday & Metro Media Group